1812-1865 Catalogue of Members
First Presbyterian Church
Town of Angelica
Allegany County New York

Try our genealogy search engine

Members of the First Presbyterian Church, Angelica, 1812-1865

A "List of Members" is a part of the "Manual for the Communicants of the First Presbyterian Church in Angelica, N. Y., Angelica": C. F. and G. W. Dickinson, 1866. The churchwas organized May 6, 1812 by Rev. John Niles, pastor of the Presbyterian Church at Bath, "consisting of Major Moses VanCampen and Margaret VanCampen, his wife; James Renwick; David Chamberlain and Elizabeth Chamerlain, and Mrs. Prudence Johnson, their daughter." The "List" is preceeded by pages on the church's history and current officers.

Pastors

• Rev. Robert Hubbard ordained and installed Aug. 20, 1812, installation on veranda of Angelica house of Evert Vanwinckle, Esq., continued to Aug. 30, 1826.
• Rev. Lewis Cheesman, supply, 1 year 3 mos.
• Rev. Moses Hunter, second pastor, Nov. 15, 1827, continued about 5 years.
• Rev. Sam'l Wells May served a short time.
• Rev. Leverett Hull, third pastor, Sept. 29, 1835

1837-1850:

• Rev. Abiel Parmelee.
• Rev. George Coan
• Rev. James Smith
• Rev. Leverett Hull
• Rev. Frazer
• Rev. Norton
• Rev. Warren
• Rev. Center

• Rev. Tyrrell Blair, fourth pastor, 1850; died 1855.
• Rev. Henry E. Niles, May 1, 1856-
• Rev. Elijah W. Stoddard, 1860-1864
• Rev. Elias L. Boing, fifth pastor, Oct. 12, 1864-

Church Officers:

• Pastor Rev. Elias L. Boing
• Pastor Rev. Abijah B. Palmer

Ruling Elders

• Alfred Lockhart
• William J. Niles
• James Benham
• Harvey S. Beals
• Jonathan E. Robinson
• David L. Hunn, Jr.

Deacons

• Vial Thomas
• Saxton Burr
• Henry Smith

Trustees

• Alfred Lockhart
• Albert Brown
• D. L. Hunn, Jr.
• George S. Arnold

List of Members in The Order of time when united

• C - admitted on profession of faith
• D - dismissed to some other church
• Ex - excommunicated
• P - admitted on profession of faith
• S - suspended
• * - died
• N - those whose manner of leaving is not recorded (substituted for dagger in original)

1812 Members

• Hubbard, Rev. Robert, C. D.
• Van Campen, Moses, P. D.
• Van Campen, Margaret, P.*
• Chamberlain, David, P.*
• Renwick, James, P.*
• Chamberlain, Elizabeth, P.*
• Johnson, Prudence, P.*
• Very, Prissila, P.*
• Graham, Betsey, P.N.

1813 Members

• Chamberlain, Hannah, P. D.
• Chamberlain, Mary, P. N.
• Van Campen, Elizabeth, P. D.
• McBridge, Philena, P. D.
• Cock, ----, P. N.
• Thomas, Vial, P.
• McKeen, John, C. N.

1817 Members

• Snellenberger, Fredrick, P.*
• Snellenberger, Magdelene, P.*
• Norton, Mary, P. D.
• Lawrence, Roxy, P. D.
• Chamberlain, Polly (?), P.*

1818 Members

• Bridgeman, Ira, P. D.
• Bridgeman, Esther, P. D.

1819 Members

• Night, Joseph, P.*
• Night, Sarah, P. N.
• Van Campen, Samuel, P. N.
• Van Campen, Martha, P. N.
• Sorter, Margaret, P. D.
• Hood, ----, P. N.
• Hood, ----, P. N.
• Weed, ----, N.
• Hall, ----, P. N.
• Van Campen, Jennie, P. N.
• Sorter, P.*

1827 Members

• Hunter, Rev. Moses, C.*
• Hopkins, Elias, C. D.
• Haight, Saml. S., C. D.
• Lloyd, Ransom, C.
• Wilson, Lydia, P. D.
• Haight, Sarah, C.*
• Buchanan, Betsey, C. D.
• Sherman, Ellen, P.*
• Engle, Susan, C. D.
• McCoy, Hannah, C. D.
• Geiger, William, P. D.
• Lawrence, Daniel, C. D.
• Geiger, Elly, P. D.
• Platt, Melissa, P. N.
• Van Campen, Mary, C. D.
• Hunter, Elizabeth, C. D.

1828 Members

• Johnson, Shubal, P.*
• Renwick, Robert, C.*
• Common, John, C.
• Hovey, Asa, C. S.
• Glover, George W., C. D.
• Littlejohn, Augustus, C.
• Sanford, Jacob, P.*
• Thomas, Ruth, P.*
• Hovey, Almira, C. N.
• Haight, Sarah, P. D.
• Haight, Hannah, P.*
• Johnson, Amy, P. N.
• Sherman, Lucy M., P.
• Common, Margaret, P.
• Shepherd, Paul, C. D.
• Shepherd, Mrs. Asenath, C. D.
• Haywood, Margaret, C. N.
• Haywood, Lydia, P. D.
• Haywood, Jane, P. D.
• Haywood, Mabel, P. N.
• Thomas, James M., P. D.
• Thomas, Wm. H., P. D.
• McCoy, Wm. Y., C. D.
• Johnson, Simon C., C. N.
• Eddy, Eliza, P. D.
• Lloyd, Clarissa, P. D.
• Lloyd, Angelina, P. D.
• Geiger, Elizabeth, P. D.
• Geiger, Hester, P. D.
• McCoy, Martha, P. D.
• Buchanan, Mary S., P. D.
• Starr, Julia M., C.
• Wilson, Jerusha A., P. D.
• Lawrence, Clemenza L., P. D.
• Lawrence, Elizabeth M., P. D.
• Clement, Lydia, P. D.
• McBridge, Hannah, P. N.
• Sherman, Emily, P.*
• Glover, Mary, P. D.
• McCoy, Caroline, P. D.

1829 Members

• Hooker, Warner, P. D.
• Dey, William, C. D.
• Schenk, Mrs. Ellen C., C. D.
• Davidson, Susan, P. D.
• Debou, Matilda, P. D.
• Marvin, Eliza Ann, P. D.
• Bromley, Julia Ann, P. Ex.
• Schenk, Mary Jane, P. D.
• Griswold, Elijah, P. D.
• Hayward, Josiah, C.
• Buchanan, John, C. D.

1830 Members

• Lawrence, Roxy L., P. D.
• Schoonover, Jabob, C. D.
• Schoonover, David, C. D.
• Schoonover, Lucy, C. D.
• Smith, Richard, C. D.
• Smith, Arena, C. D.
• Bailey, Dorothy, C. D.

1831 Members

• Smith, William, C. D.
• Buchanan, Samuel, C. D.
• Merritt, Peter, C. D.
• Merritt, Polly E., C. D.
• Merritt, Lucy C., C. D.
• Smith, Leonard, C.
• Smith, Elizabeth, C.*
• Dudley, Elon, P.
• Starr, Sophia L., P.
• Van Wormer, Aaron, P. D.
• Rounds, Sylvester, C. N.
• Geiger, Catharine, P. D.
• Webber, Rachel C., P. D.
• Hunt, Armenia E., P. N.
• Benton, Youngs E., C. D.
• Benton, Mary Ann, C. D.
• Ranney, Nathaniel C., C. D.
• Ranney, Minerva M., C. D.
• Hill, Cornelia E., C. D.
• Dudley, Fanny Smith, P.
• Chase, Benjamin, C. D.
• Chase, Mehetabel, C. D.
• Chase, Betsey Ann, P. D.
• Dryer, Nancy B., P. D.
• Webber, Miranda, P. D.
• Dean, Nancy, C. D.

1832 Members

• Furness, James E., C. D.
• Burr, Anna, P.*
• Patrick, Rachel, C. D.
• Bailey, Mary, P. D.
• Dean, Daniel, P. D.
• Kingsbury, Lewis H., P. D.
• Dean, Mary, P. D.
• Merritt, Bazina (?), P. D.
• Crist, Mrs. Sarah J., C. N.

1833 Members

• Rawson, Isaac, Jr., P.
• Allen, Rev. Asa S., C.
• Allen, Lydia, C. D.
• Tyler, Silas G., C. D.
• Tyler, Almira, C. D.
• Dean, William, P. D.
• Elliott, Luman, P. D.
• Benton, Rev. Joseph A., P. D.
• Dean, Charles, P. D.
• Weaver, James, P. D.
• Weaver, Clarissa, P. D.
• Benton, Experience, P. D.
• Dean, Maria, P. D.

1834 Members

• Breck, Joseph, C. D.
• Breck, Betsey, C. D.
• Breck, Caroline, C.
• Hawks, Silas, C. N.
• Barber, Joseph, C.
• Hawks, Eunice, C. N.
• Wyllys, Aroe L., C. D.
• Crosby, Amos H., C. D.
• Halladay, Rhoda, C. N.
• Cooley, Mrs. Persis M., C.
• Smith, Henry, C.
• Smith, Margaret, C. D.
• Phelps, Josiah, P. D.
• Phelps, Aurelia, P. D.
• Wyllys, Laura, P. D.
• Benson, Henry J., P. D.
• Benson, Julia J., P. D.

1835 Members

• Patrick, Charles, P. D.
• Wickham, Aaron, P.
• Wyllys, Suel, P.*
• Chase, Cyrus, P. D.
• Smith, Frederick H., P. N.
• Arnold, James C., P.
• Rawson, Rhoda, P.*
• Jones, Amanda, P. D.
• Drown, Almira, P. D.
• Hill, Susan, P. N.
• Carpenter, David H., P.
• Alvord, Eliza M., P. N.
• Latham, Waity M., P. N.
• Waterman, Elizabeth, P. D.
• Breck, Elizabeth, P. D.
• Burns, Mary, P. D.
• Howard, Lorana, P. D.
• Howard, Dolly Diana, P. D.
• Could, Clarissa, P.
• Wickham, Martha, P.
• Lusk, Elizabeth, C. D.
• Gould, Elizabeth, P. D.
• Allen, Harriet, P.
• Smith, Mary, P. D.
• Drury, Amasa, C. D.
• Burt, Henry, C.
• Smith, Susan Ann, P.
• Smith, Harriet, P. D.
• Burt, Fanny B., C. N.
• Patridge, Elisabeth, C.
• Randall, Maryetta, C. D.
• Pray, Nathan, C. N.
• Barnetson, Alexander, C.*
• Breck, Allen Y., C. D.
• Schuyler, Philemon, C. N.
• Patridge, Dennis, P. Ex.
• Chase, Henry, P. D.
• Dean, Mary, P. D.
• Randall, Sarah, P. D.
• Bromley, Julia, P. N.
• Thomas, James, P. N.
• Chase, Salina, P.
• Franklin, Lydia M., P. N.
• Howard, Fanny, P. D.
• Sherman, Bildad, P.*
• Drown, Simeon De Witt, P. D.
• Drown, Sarah, P. D.
• Breck, William, P. D.
• Burr, Harriet, P.
• Thomas, Harriet, P. D.
• Adams, Eliza, P.
• Staniford, Horatio, P. D.
• Staniford, Louisa, P. D.
• Jones, Otis, P. D.
• Jones, Harriet, P. D.
• Rawson, Isaac, P. Ex.
• Merritt, Noble, P. D.
• Merritt, Betsey, P. D.
• Drury, Erric, P. D.
• Lloyd, Harrison, P. D.
• Halladay, Loranda, P.
• Lawrence, Almira, P.
• Diven, Alexander S., C.
• Diven, Amanda, C.
• Howard, Minerva, P.
• Alton, Nancy Ann, P.
• Breck, Samuel P., P. D.
• Rutherford, Jennette, P.*
• Clapp, Agile, P. D.
• Clapp, Julia Ann, P. D.
• Carrier, Zirzah, P. D.
• Renwick, Ruth, P.
• Chamberlain, Elijah, P. D.
• Hoagland, Ezra, P. D.
• Andrews, James H., C. D.
• McOmber, Simeon, C. D.
• Hull, Sarah L., C. D.
• Sadler, Adeline, C. D.
• Wiley, Joanna M., P. N.
• Prentiss, Stephen, C.*
• Prentiss, Clarissa, C. D.
• Prentiss, Narcissa, C. D.
• Prentiss, Clarissa, C. D.
• Prentiss, Harriet, C. D.
• Prentiss, Jane A., C. D.
• Prentiss, Edward W., C. D.

1836 Members

• Smith, Henry, C.
• Smith, Mary, P.
• Smith, Hiram, P.
• Smith, Elizabeth, P.
• Prentiss, Jonas G., P. D.
• Prentiss, Francis R., C. D.
• Renwick, John, P.
• McHenry, Margaret, P. D.
• Shattuck, Betsey, C.
• Waterman, Nancy, P. D.
• Webb, Henry J., P.
• Webb, Mary Ann, P.*
• Drury, Judith, P. D.
• Bailey, Susan, P. D.
• Fuller, Alfred, P. D.
• Patridge, Ira, P. Ex.
• Dryer, Thomas J., PPEx
• Haydon, Nathaniel, P.*
• Haydon, Sarah M., P.
• Breck, George W., P. D.
• Merritt, Simeon, P. N.
• Hough, Eliphalet R., P.
• Boughton, Eliza, P.*
• Fuller, Laura R., P. D.
• Hull, Laurens, C.*
• Hull, Dorcas A., C.*
• Hill, Alathea, C.*
• Waldo, Eunice, P. D.
• Bruce, E. S., C. D.
• Taylor, Mrs., P.*
• Braithwait, Abigail, P. D.

1837 Members

• Hull, Betsey, P.
• Babcock, Thomas, P. D.
• Foster, Daniel, C. D.
• Foster, Lucy Ann, C. D.
• McCain, Mahlon, C. D.
• McCain, Matilda, C. D.
• McCain, Alfred, C. D.
• Johnson, Olive, C. D.

1838 Members

• Johnson, Mrs. Marietta, C. D.
• Procter, Mrs. Ruth, C. D.

1840 Members

• Van Wickle, Esther, P.*
• Rawson, Rhoda, P.*
• Thomas, Charles K., P. D.
• Thomas, George W., P.
• Baker, Julia, P.*
• Gleason, Sarah, P.
• Miles, Harvey, P.
• Robinson, Minerva, P. D.
• Taylor, Meliss, P. Ex.
• Hull, Elizabeth, P. D.
• Hull, Cornelia S., P. D.
• Schoonover, Edward, P. D.
• Prentiss, Nancy Jane, P. N.
• Freeman, Harriet, P. N.
• Carpenter, Richard E., P.
• Hull, Henry D., P. N.
• Gleason, Erastus, P. Ex.
• Slater, Melissa, P.*
• Childs, Solomon S., P. D.
• Hull, Marcus A., P. S.
• Lockhart, Alfred, C.
• Perrin, Eveline, C. S.
• Prentiss, Jonas G., C.
• White, Spencer, C.

1841 Members

• Starr, Ezra, C.*
• Dean, William, C.*
• Dean, Nancy, C.*
• Dean, Caroline, C.*
• Coan, Mabel N., C. D.
• Coan, Rev. George M., C. D.
• Coan, Caroline Antoinette, C. D.

1843 Members

• Prime, David P., P. D.
• Prime, Nancy, P. D.
• Rice, Mores, C. D.
• Rice, Clarissa, C. D.
• Lincoln, Horace, C.
• Smith, Sarah R., C. D.
• Lockhart, Sarah, C.
• Buzby, Julia Ann, C.*

1844 Members

• Webb, Susan, C.
• Haight, Theodore, C.
• Miller, John, C. N.
• Miller, Susanna, C. N.
• Miller, Sarah, C.*
• Sheldon, Eliza, C. D.
• Burr, Mary, C.
• Burr, Myron H., P.

1845 Members

• Palmer, Anna M., C. D.
• Fraser, Sarah, C. D.
• Philenda, Norton, C. D.

1847 Members

• Furman, Scoby, C.*
• Bell, John, C.
• Bell, Sarah, C.*
• Littlejohn, Mary Ann, C.*
• Furman, Jane, P. D.

1849 Members

• Stores, Abigail, C.
• Rutheford, Andrew, C.*
• Rutherford, Elizabeth, C.*
• Burr, Adaline, C. D.
• Graves, Lydia Ann, C. D.
• Gardner, Julia Ann, C. D.
• Easton, Matilda, C. N.
• Hull, Azel P., C. S.
• Hull, Ruth Ann, C.
• Thornton, Martha, P.

1851 Members

• Smith, Eliza, C. D.
• Smith, Catharine, C. D.
• Wood, Diana, P.*
• Bell, Maria, C.
• Blair, Sarah M., C.
• Thomas, James M., C.
• Thoms, Clarissa, C.
• Gould, Tirza, C. D.
• Lindsay, ---, C. D.
• Fish, Emily P., P. D.
• Colson, William B., C. D.
• Colson, Nancy M., C. D.
• Wheeler, Eliza, C. D.
• Bell, Mary E., P.
• Burr, Saxton, C.
• Burr, Susan M., C.*

1852 Members

• Lockwood, Andrew B., C. D.
• Ranny, Harriet, C. D.
• Bell, Sarah J., P. D.
• Norton, Mary, P. D.
• Bell, Rachel, P. D.
• Webb, Ellen M., P. D.
• Wetsell, Charles C., C. D.
• Wetsell, ---, C.*
• Lincoln, Elizabeth C., P.
• Hunn, David L., Jr., C.

1853 Members

• Hunn, Elisabeth, C.*
• Benham, James, C.
• Benham, Julia H., C.
• Dey, William, C.*
• Dey, Hannah, C.*
• Dey, John, P.
• Dey, Mary, P.
• Rice, Mira A., C. D.
• East, William, P. D.
• Heckman, Louisa H., P.*

1855 Members

• Beals, Harvey S., C.
• Beals, Harriet N., C.

1856 Members

• Burr, Myron H., C. D.
• Burr, Mary E., C. D.
• Buck, H. A., C. D.
• Buck, ---, C. D.
• Platt, Joseph, C.
• Platt, Alvira C., C.
• Terry, Adaline, C.*
• Heckman, Rebecca S.
• Lewis, Mary Elisabeth, P. D.
• Burr, Fanny, P.*
• Blair, Ellen Minerva, P. D.
• Smith, Mary Jane, C.
• Niles, William J., C.
• Brown, Louisa M., C.
• ---, ---, C. D.
• Maltby, Stephen L., C. D.
• ---, ---, C. D.
• Maltby, Maria N., C. D.
• ---, ---, P.*
• Maltby, Sarah P., P.*
• ---, ---, C. P.
• Willis, Caroline E., C. P.
• ---, ---, P. D.
• Merritt, Cornelia L., P. D.
• ---, ---, P.*
• Bell, Rebecca E., P.*
• ---, ---, P.
• Heckman, Rachel E., P. D.
• Heckman, Emma, P.

1857 Members

• Alley, Caroline M., C. D.
• Beals, Sarah A., P.
• Carney, Mary, P.
• Smith, Maria L., P.
• Barnetson, Cynthia F., P.
• Smith, Ann Matilda, P.
• Lloyd, Julia Starr, P.
• White, Sarah E., P. D.
• Thomas, Mary Sophia, P.
• Platt, Caroline Adel, P. S.
• Fuller, Mary Frances, C. P. D.
• Eggleston, Jane H., P.
• Carpenter, Emily E., P.
• Rathbun, Lucy M., P.
• Benham, Azel Morse, P. D.
• Arnold, George Starr, P.
• Chamberlain, Alonzo W., P.
• Erdelmeyer, Francis, P.
• Goodrich, John Olmsted, P.
• Burr, Edwin Stone, P.
• Magee, Julia A., P. D.
• Hammond, Elsie, P.
• Smith, William W., C. D.
• Smith, Orilla, C. D.
• Palmer, Abijah B., C.
• Palmer, Alma, C.
• Lincoln, Emily, C.
• Grummond, Atalinda, C.
• Lloyd, Harlan Page, P.
• White, Susan, P.
• Huntley, Letta Jane, P.

1858 Members

• Niles, Jeanie E., C. D.
• Bell, Martha E., P.
• Arnold, Eliza S., P.
• Lloyd, Cornelia L., P.
• Ranney, Julia A., P. D.
• Niles, Susan H., P.
• Smith, Lavina B., P. D.
• Blair, Edward, P. D.
• Balthasar, Agustus D., P. S.
• Smith, Hannah, P.
• Fish, Lucia Hull, P.
• Johnson, Susan E., P. D.
• Malthy, Martha Sophia, P. D.
• Bell, Margaret Caroline, P.
• Rice, Emily, P.
• Burnham, Sarah O., P.
• Moon, Sarah S., P.
• Fish, Mary Stephens, P.
• Young, Elizabeth, P. D.
• Chase, Emily C., C. D.

1859 Members

• Horner, Elizabeth P., P.
• Brown, Diantha, P. D.

1860 Members

• Angel, Cornelia, C.

1861 Members

• Hartshorn, Maria Cordelia, P.
• Camp, Frances Ellen, P.*
• Dennison, Harriet Melinda, P.
• Little, Mary Elizabeth, P.*
• Concklin, Eliza O., C. D.
• Stoddard, Eliza W., C. D.
• Burr, Gertrude, P.*

1862 Member

• Burt, Alfred D., C. D.
• Goodale, Rhoda, C. D.
• Dildine, Emeline G., C.
• Holliday, Roxana, P.
• Lockhart, Henrietta, P.
• Hunn, Eunice S., C.
• Hunn, Susan J., C.
• Stoddard, Samuel, C. D.
• Ferguson, Sarah, C.
• Taylor, Roxana S., C.
• Stewart, Mary, C.

1863 Members

• Chamberlain, Almond W., C.
• Chamberlain, Matilda, C.
• Brown, Henry, PI

1864 Members

• Burr, Ann Elizabeth, P.
• Lloyd, Lucy Ida, P.
• Martin, Hettie Priscilla, P.
• Burr, Nancy Catherine, P.
• Bullard, Mary Elizabeth, P.
• Cochran, Edward, P.
• Cochran, Jane, P.
• Stockwell, Eli, C.
• Stockwell, Almira, C.
• Arnold, Charles P., C.

1865 Members

• Bradley, George T., P.
• Wheeler, Lucy Eliza, P.
• Boing, Anna Maria, C.
• Chamberlain, Cynthia R., C.
• Smith, Almira, P.
• Margeson, Elisabeth, P.
• Young, Edward, P. D.
• White, Harriet, P.
• Webb, Henry J., P.
• Forsyth, Edward A., P.
• Van Winkle, Flora, P.
• Burdick, Helen, P.
• Wheeler, Aaron W., P.
• Wilson, Hattie, P.
• Brown, Albert, P.
• Brown, Ellen Sarah, P.
• Brown, Hattie Olmsted, P.
• Cook, George W., P.
• Cook, Lois, P.
• Robinson, Johnathan E., C.
• Robinson, Emily, C.
• Robinson, Fred Hall, P.
• Robinson, Mary, C.
• Wood, Frances Maria, P.
• Horner, Susan Louisa, P.
• Smith, Emma, P.
• Smith, Hattie Newell, P.
• Smith, Electa Jane, P.
• King, Sarah L., C.
• Hancock, John, P.
• Ferenbaugh, Daniel P., P.
• Ferenbaugh, Katw, P.
• Bixby, Chandler, C.
• Bixby, Urania, C.

New Horizons Genealogy
Copyright © 2023 All rights reserved
Privacy Policy | Disclaimer | Contact us